The $100 Billion Media Opportunity for Retailers
Retailers can supercharge their personalization efforts and start a virtuous flywheel spinning.
By Lauren Wiener, Leora Kelman, Kale Hungerson, and Mark Abraham
Top retailers are tapping into the high-growth, high-margin business of retail media to aggressively fund strategies that boost their priorities and competitive position. In so doing, they are not only disrupting the digital advertising industry, but also transforming the retail landscape. So far, large companies have led the way in retail media, creating urgency for companies of all sizes to seize and maximize this opportunity or risk losing out to the early adopters.
As retail media continues to transform and grow at an accelerated pace, BCG has partnered with Google to understand how companies can best position themselves to expand their retail media business. BCG interviewed and surveyed more than 50 retail media leaders and experts across the sectors of omni-retail, pure-play e-commerce, travel, and auto. Our research offers a deep dive into market dynamics and the tactical next steps that businesses of various sizes should take to capture this opportunity as they plan for the year.
We estimate that the retail media market will grow by 25% per year to $100 billion over the next five years and will account for over 25% of total digital media spending by 2026. Seemingly every week, a news headline trumpets the launch of a new retail media network, from Michael’s (arts and crafts supplies) to Nordstrom (department store). A retail media network is essentially an advertising business that a retailer sets up in order to allow advertisers to buy advertising space across the retailer’s owned (onsite) properties and paid (offsite) media, using consumer data to connect with consumers throughout the buyer journey.
The strength of retail media reflects the fact that advertisers like the visibility of performance provided by closed-loop measurement capabilities—the ability to tie a media campaign back to omni-channel sales. Its success both as a business opportunity and as a marketing channel is prompting other industries, such as travel and auto, to boost investment in this area. We estimate that media revenue from the expanded group of industries that we call “commerce media” could add $10 billion on top of the baseline $100 billion net revenue estimate for retail media in the US over the next five years. (See Exhibit 1.)
While many larger entrants began their retail media initiatives by monetizing their owned channels, many small or midsize players have used offsite channels to enter the retail media market quickly. In fact, offsite offers major advantages for players of all sizes because it simultaneously expands a company’s reach to a larger audience and drives that audience to the company’s own website, thus helping it scale its onsite business. These dynamics enable a company to save money by, in effect, cofunding its own advertising. Because onsite and offsite reinforce each other so powerfully, a company needs both in order to establish a mature retail media network.
A particularly compelling aspect of this retail media opportunity—and part of what makes it so transformative—is the potential to achieve enormous profit margins. By our estimate, the $110 billion commerce media market will yield almost $75 billion in profits in 2026. Our research suggests that spending by advertisers on retailers’ owned channels will grow at a rate of 22% per year over the next five years, with robust margins of 70% to 90%. Offsite media spending is growing even faster—at 35% per year—with margins in the range of 20% to 40%, after media costs and/or agency management fees. Significantly, even though the gross margin range for offsite spending is lower than the corresponding range for onsite spending, it is competitive with the gross margin for most retail categories. (See Exhibit 2.) Because of the differential growth, we anticipate that the proportions of onsite and offsite spending over the next five years will shift toward offsite, at approximately 70% and 30%, respectively.
Leading companies are reinvesting the profits from these high margins in their business. They are lowering prices, updating technology, and improving marketing to enhance the customer experience. This year, for the first time, Amazon and Walmart reported results specifically for their advertising business, revealing the degree to which retail media is subsidizing these companies’ broader strategy. This is especially true of Amazon, where retail media profits offset losses in the broader retail business. (See Exhibit 3.)
Companies of all sizes need to devise a retail media offering as both a defensive strategy (to hold their proportional share of historical trade dollars) and an offensive strategy (to capture the new money on the table).
Control and transparency are orders of magnitude better in retail media businesses than in traditional approaches to trade spending, sponsorships, events, and promotions. This advantage enables brands to measure and monitor performance closely and to adjust spending allocations in channels or ad units. The benefits are so great for marketers (which are under pressure to demonstrate returns) that companies without a retail media offering are sure to lose out to competitors. Having a retail media offering will therefore become a critical defensive strategy for holding onto trade dollars.
On the offensive side, retailers are going after new dollars. We estimate that 60% to 70% of the projected $100 billion in 2026 retail media revenue will be net new spending over and above historical trade dollars. (See Exhibit 4.) New sources include organic growth in digital advertising, as well as a shift from incumbents and traditional channels. Each of these funding pools represents an opportunity for retail media businesses to promote themselves to marketers and advertisers looking for channels with promising ROI and first-party audience targeting that avoids customer privacy issues.
Leaders have already emerged in retail media. Amazon will continue to be the biggest player in the space, accounting for 60% of retail media. (See Exhibit 5.) Behind Amazon a few major retailers, such as Walmart and Target, will mount media networks in excess of $1 billion, accounting for 25% of the space. Going forward, however, we anticipate significant growth among smaller players; in fact, we estimate that they will grow more rapidly than Amazon or any of the other leaders over the next five years.
Although growth will accelerate for smaller players, three factors will continue to be favorable to early entrants:
These three factors (customer, media buyers, and technology) will certainly benefit current leaders, but it is not too late for others to find success—if they act quickly. Marketers and advertisers will need ways to reach unique customers in different places, and we expect multiple leaders to emerge in each industry. In addition, the trade reallocation share of retail media (30% to 40% of the $100 billion market) is likely to mimic current trade allocations if companies’ competitive offerings are similar. Thus, we anticipate opportunities for category specialists with media networks of between $100 million and $1 billion, as well as for niche players with media networks of less than $100 million. Companies that don’t put a retail media strategy in place soon are likely to lose out to a rival in their category that does.
Each industry in the broader definition of commerce media is at a unique point of maturity. For example, the travel vertical has a variety of mature media networks, retailers are accelerating their involvement to maximize their massive customer access, and most auto aggregators are nascent but looking for growth opportunities.
Our survey indicates that companies of different sizes are at different points of maturity in three key dimensions: data, product and technology, and people. In all three dimensions, larger players are generally more mature than segment specialists, which in turn are more mature than niche players. On the basis of what we’ve learned, we suggest the following initiatives going forward.
For leaders, the focus should be on centralization of data, effective use of application programming interfaces (APIs), and expanding scale:
For category specialists, investing in audience-building capabilities, articulating the value proposition, and adopting agile methodologies are paramount:
For niche players, priorities should include developing rapid forecasting capabilities, deploying proofs of concept (POCs), and bolstering sales and monetization roles within the company:
Retail media is a rapidly growing, high-margin advertising channel. But success in retail media is about more than just mastering this new channel. It involves using this enormous new profit pool to reinvest in the business and redefine the company’s competitive advantage in its core business. These conditions create urgency for companies of all sizes to enter the space quickly and grow their retail media revenue, or risk losing out to competitors that do.
The conclusions in this article represent BCG’s views only and not those of any third party involved in the supporting study. Many thanks to Vincent Ho and Maslen Ward, who supported this research.
ABOUT BOSTON CONSULTING GROUP
Boston Consulting Group partners with leaders in business and society to tackle their most important challenges and capture their greatest opportunities. BCG was the pioneer in business strategy when it was founded in 1963. Today, we work closely with clients to embrace a transformational approach aimed at benefiting all stakeholders—empowering organizations to grow, build sustainable competitive advantage, and drive positive societal impact.
Our diverse, global teams bring deep industry and functional expertise and a range of perspectives that question the status quo and spark change. BCG delivers solutions through leading-edge management consulting, technology and design, and corporate and digital ventures. We work in a uniquely collaborative model across the firm and throughout all levels of the client organization, fueled by the goal of helping our clients thrive and enabling them to make the world a better place.
© Boston Consulting Group 2024. All rights reserved.
For information or permission to reprint, please contact BCG at permissions@bcg.com. To find the latest BCG content and register to receive e-alerts on this topic or others, please visit bcg.com. Follow Boston Consulting Group on Facebook and X (formerly Twitter).
Retailers can supercharge their personalization efforts and start a virtuous flywheel spinning.
There’s gold at the end of the personalization rainbow. To get it, retailers need to focus on the customer experience, technology, and operating models.
Four accelerators enable more advanced companies to outperform.
Customers expect a personalized shopping experience. All retailers—even leaders—must advance their capabilities to deliver it.
Companies looking to make a step change in customer and consumer engagement should investigate this powerful new technology now.