This brief is based on the article “Turning Superheroes into a Super Leadership Team.”
A senior leadership team is pivotal to a CEO’s success. When nimble and aligned around the path forward, the team can mobilize the organization effectively to execute the chief executive’s vision. But when it’s not on the same page—or worse, when it’s dysfunctional—the odds of steering the company to peak performance and keeping it there sorely diminish.
Talented individuals alone do not guarantee effectiveness. As many CEOs can attest, it’s one thing to lead a business unit successfully, and quite another to operate as part of a senior leadership team that moves together quickly to deliver continuous growth, break new ground, and stay ahead of the competition.
The problem is often rooted in the very qualities that tend to vault managers into the top ranks. Many carve their path by pursuing bold plans for an individual domain where standout results can pivot on guarding resources and putting their team’s interests first—even before the organization’s. This mindset can become even more ingrained in corporate cultures that reward individual “heroics,” such as putting out fires or navigating successfully through a crisis.
Simply put, many companies have superheroes. Few have super teams.
Standard fixes, such as jetting off to an attractive location to engage in immersive team-building exercises, can inject a renewed sense of optimism into an underperforming senior leadership team. It may even get team members to start thinking about enterprise-wide priorities. But it’s unlikely to stick.
Embedding an enterprise-first mindset means changing how the team engages with each other and the rest of the company. The team needs to reframe every decision to determine if it’s right for the whole enterprise and consistent with its purpose, strategy, and priorities. Incentives may need to be revisited and aligned to discourage siloed thinking and reward actions that lift the entire organization.
Building a leadership team also requires sacrifice. There will be times when a senior leader will need to pause or sunset a pet project, or possibly eliminate positions in their domain, for the good of the whole company.
This is hard stuff, but when organizations are guided by “The Head, Heart, and Hands” of holistic, human-centric transformation, it is possible to turn a group of individual superheroes into an unbeatable super team.
It starts by identifying the most pressing priorities the team should focus on, the decisions that should remain in its purview, and those that can be delegated down. The team must build mutual trust, understanding, and transparency so each member feels supported by their peers and people throughout the organization feel empowered and inspired to work collaboratively in the service of the greater goals. This is crucial—when the Head and Heart are in the right place, the senior leadership team can put the Hands to work by developing a roadmap that translates enterprise-wide priorities into actions.
Super teams don’t thrive on autopilot. They need a sustained and sometimes uncomfortable level of individual and collective self-reflection to stay on top of the team’s current state, where the team needs to be, and the behaviors that stand in the way of progress. They need to maintain their commitment to common goals and practice unlearning old habits, all of which take vigilance.
Most senior leadership teams are comprised of incredibly smart, talented individuals. They know when the team is not delivering like it should. Where they get stuck is letting go of the mindsets and behaviors that undermine effectiveness. But with the right approach, reflection, commitment, and practice, superheroes can indeed become a super team.
In a complex, fast-changing world, team members must shift from championing their own domains to putting the enterprise first. Here’s how to make it happen.
Explore the article that informed this brief
Jim Hemerling is a leader in Boston Consulting Group’s People & Organization and Transformation practices, as well as the firm's behavior and culture topic. He is also a BCG Henderson Institute Alumni Fellow.
Jennifer Thomas is Founder and Director of the Leadership Coaching offering at Boston Consulting Group. She has more than 20 years of experience developing and coaching C-suite executives, senior leaders, consultants, and non-profit leaders.
Related Content
Explore more insights from The CEO Agenda and BCG’s experts.
CEOs have become more cautious and strategic about taking public stands on politically charged issues. But upcoming elections will put this measured approach to the test.
Senior leaders say middle management is a sticking point; individual contributors say it’s not meeting needs; middle managers themselves say the role is a source of burnout. BCG’s Julia Dhar imagines a future in which AI takes over multiple aspects of middle management.
The CEO’s role will evolve into something far different: chief ecosystem orchestrator. Responsibilities and the skills required to successfully lead will shift significantly. BCG’s Judith Wallenstein explains how these CEOs of the future could navigate the blurred boundaries among companies, industries, and nations.
Retention is a complex issue unique to each company, but research suggests a universal solution: doubling down on employee joy.