Why are so many retail promotions wasteful? Many retailers are asking themselves that question, and with good reason. From 30% to 40% of retail promotions not only are either inefficient or unprofitable, but also risk alienating consumers by overwhelming them with choices that make shopping harder. These inefficiencies have two primary causes:
Attempting to reduce promotional intensity, however, presents several challenges. First, retailers face a prisoner’s dilemma. Making unilateral cuts in promotions without adopting offsetting measures is a sure-fire way to lose consumers to other retailers. Second, because many retailers cannot gauge the effects of different promotions precisely, they struggle to decide which ones to cut and which to keep and improve. Without those insights, efforts to optimize promotions could have the opposite effect and leave a retailer in a no-man’s land between heavy promoters and every-day-low-price (EDLP) retailers. Winning in EDLP requires a consistent, loud-and-clear message to consumers, accompanied by intensive cost management to beat out competitors on price. Very few retailers are in a position to do that well.
Well-planned, well-executed promotions can play a critical role in retailers’ overall value strategy by helping them effectively communicate their value proposition and shape consumer perceptions.
But this assumes that the retailer is clear and confident about what that value strategy is before optimizing the promotional strategy to support it.
Retailers generally play what we refer to as the Uniform Game, in which they share value with consumers by offering uniform prices aimed at striking a balance between volume and margin. Thanks to the vast progress in data collection and AI capabilities in recent years, retailers now have opportunities to switch their value-sharing strategy to the Choice Game, which emphasizes balance across the entire portfolio rather than the success of any individual product. The most sophisticated retailers could switch from the Uniform Game to the Dynamic Game, with the goal of sharing value with individual consumers and adjusting prices and promotions in real time.
In line with the game they choose, many retailers would benefit from taking a holistic view of their promotional activities across three dimensions: strategy, measurement, and execution. Superior tools are now available to help them become smarter and more strategic about which promotions to run.
The needs of consumers often play only a minor role in retailers’ promotional planning process. Instead, the typical process involves taking the previous year’s promotional plan as a starting point and adjusting it on the basis of what suppliers want to push and co-fund. Facing short-term sales pressures, merchants often try to maximize promotional spending despite poor ROIs.
By redefining their plans from a consumer-centric standpoint, retailers can identify the consumer behaviors they want to drive, understand how consumers perceive different promotions, and determine why one promotion may be likelier than others to induce the desired behavior. This helps retailers set clear objectives for individual promotions as well as for their entire program.
Simplicity is key to influencing behavior. Over half of consumers in our survey preferred promotions that are easy to understand versus more complicated promotions. The design of a promotion—including target consumers, discount intensity, and promotion duration—should reflect critical thinking about the intended change in consumer behavior. (See Exhibit 1.) These strategic goals need to come together in a targeted promotion plan.
The role of promotions, the behaviors companies want to encourage, and consumers’ perceptions can vary considerably by category, brand, and item. For this reason, business and consumer insights play an integral role in the design of a promotion. Ensuring that every promotion has a clear rationale can help drive incremental changes in consumer behavior, rather than reinforcing existing behaviors or subsidizing sales that would have occurred anyway.
Consider items designed to meet an immediate need, such as on-the-go meals or cough medicine, which consumers generally buy only when necessary. Although promotions can motivate consumers to choose a specific brand or item, they exert minimal influence on the fundamental decision to make a purchase. In such situations, it is more critical to have a competitive list price that consumers will remember. In contrast, promotions are much more effective at driving purchases of impulse buys such as snacks or beverages.
Promotional planning can be trickier for bigger-ticket items that consumers purchase less frequently, such as an espresso machine, a television, or an outdoor grill. Faced with greater differences in functionality, price point, and even buying occasion (for example, gift or personal use, primary or secondary unit, first-time purchase or return buy), consumers tend to do more research. Retailers who sell such items may benefit from a move to the Choice Game by restructuring the portfolio on a segment-specific basis that reduces the need for—and the relevance of—blanket promotions. Instead of subsidizing purchases that would have happened anyway, promotions should focus on driving incremental behavior. Because buying circumstances can vary widely from one consumer to another, personalized offers are especially effective in these situations.
Retailers can make better data-driven decisions once they have defined a clear promotional strategy. Often, however, they have a distorted view of the true impact of promotions, because measuring incremental uplifts is so difficult. Obtaining an accurate reading of ROI entails accounting for factors such as cannibalization, pull-forward, competitors’ actions, and seasonality. But the reward is great: a more accurate picture of promotional effectiveness helps retailers drive greater accountability and make more informed decisions. The more complex a retailer’s environment (reflecting such variables as high competition and more diverse consumers), the more the retailer will benefit from investing in advanced analytics capabilities.
Data quality plays a key role in improving both ROI calculations and the consumer insights that inform decisions. The worst situation for a retailer is to imagine itself to be data-driven when in fact it relies on low-quality data and analytics. A retailer must equip itself with data on past promotions, and it must ensure that it can correct and adjust for factors such as price changes, marketing intensity, and competitor behavior tailored to its specific business context.
Although many retailers have adopted some form of promotion software solution, not all are seeing meaningful value from this effort, for several reasons:
In-market coordination remains a challenge for many retailers. Consumers struggle to form any consistent perception when they encounter an uncoordinated mix of promotions, discounts, coupons, and loyalty rewards piled on top of each other. Some events get lost in the mix, while others fail to tap their full power. This tends to be driven by three core issues (see Exhibit 2):
Rigorously addressing the dimensions of strategy, measurement, and execution can help retailers define a consistent value proposition that they can clearly communicate to consumers. By doing so, retailers can build loyalty, enhance brand reputation, and gain access to new revenue opportunities.
To excel in overall promotion management, a retailer should make savings readily visible to consumers (for example, at checkout or on their receipts) and remind consumers of their accumulated savings over time (for example, through in-app messaging or via email). However, this approach will be successful only if the retailer addresses all three dimensions systematically.
Managing Director & Senior Partner; Global Leader, Marketing, Sales & Pricing Practice
San Francisco - Bay Area
Partner
Silicon Valley - Bay Area
Partner
Detroit
Project Leader
Seattle
Project Leader
San Francisco - Bay Area
ABOUT BOSTON CONSULTING GROUP
Boston Consulting Group partners with leaders in business and society to tackle their most important challenges and capture their greatest opportunities. BCG was the pioneer in business strategy when it was founded in 1963. Today, we work closely with clients to embrace a transformational approach aimed at benefiting all stakeholders—empowering organizations to grow, build sustainable competitive advantage, and drive positive societal impact.
Our diverse, global teams bring deep industry and functional expertise and a range of perspectives that question the status quo and spark change. BCG delivers solutions through leading-edge management consulting, technology and design, and corporate and digital ventures. We work in a uniquely collaborative model across the firm and throughout all levels of the client organization, fueled by the goal of helping our clients thrive and enabling them to make the world a better place.
© Boston Consulting Group 2024. All rights reserved.
For information or permission to reprint, please contact BCG at permissions@bcg.com. To find the latest BCG content and register to receive e-alerts on this topic or others, please visit bcg.com. Follow Boston Consulting Group on Facebook and X (formerly Twitter).
Brick-and-mortar retailers rely heavily on promotions yet often lack a strategic approach. Implementing a four-part solution can help increase promotion margins by 2 to 5 percentage points.
There’s gold at the end of the personalization rainbow. To get it, retailers need to focus on the customer experience, technology, and operating models.
Companies need to know what works for each individual customer.
BCG and Shopify looked at 1 billion data points across more than 220,000 sites to determine the best ways for sellers to optimize their e-commerce conversion rates.
