Managing Director & Senior Partner; Global Leader, Technology, Media, & Telecommunications Practice
Singapore
By Vaishali Rastogi, Derek Kennedy, Ernesto Pagano, Franck Luisada, Simon Bamberger, Nikita Garg, Val Elbert, and Hady Farag
The AI revolution is underway, transforming the telecommunications, media, and technology sectors. Our 2024 TMT Value Creators Report clearly shows the results: companies that deploy, deliver, and create the infrastructure for this remarkable technology enjoy some of the strongest rises in revenues and valuations.
For this report, our core metric is total shareholder return, measured over five years to limit the impact of short-term market moves. All data is annualized, and median figures are used for sectors to reduce the influence of outliers. The data analyzes 343 public companies globally.
The mood is very different from our previous report, when the “tech winter” slashed returns, a downturn so severe that tech companies slipped from first place to third in our ranking of five-year TSR from 33 sectors. The impact on the media sector was still more severe; it slipped from mid-ranked 15th to almost the bottom of the rankings at 27th. Only the telco sector improved its five-year ranking, from 29th to 26th, as investors valued its utility-like characteristics.
Fast-forward to the end of 2023, however, and tech companies’ valuations had rebounded with such velocity that they were back at the top of the rankings—and with a lead over other industries unprecedented in the 26 years of BCG Value Creator reports. Media stocks, too, moved up significantly, to 13th from 27th place. For telcos, median shareholder return improved, but by much less than most other sectors; as a result, their ranking slid to 31st from 26th.
Across the board, TMT benefited from cooling inflation and a brighter economic outlook in many markets, particularly the US. Demand continued to be driven by the digitization of every facet of business and personal life. For some companies, fast-recovering margins turbocharged the rebound; improved revenues fed straight into the bottom line thanks to previous cost optimization. And the outlook for dealmaking appears brighter: global M&A deal value in the first quarter of 2024 was 18.5% higher than the same quarter of 2023, according to S&P Global Data, although the volume of deals remains depressed. (See “Three Strategies for Future Value Creation” later in the report for strategies to maximize this opportunity.)
Our other key metric is value creation, measuring the absolute increase in market capitalization plus dividends distributed over five years. TMT companies created an astonishing $15 trillion in value during our five-year study period, with $14 trillion coming from the tech sector alone, more than 90% of the total. This performance was enough to boost the entire US market, the world’s largest by capitalization. Much of the buzz about the US stock market in 2023 centered on the “Magnificent Seven” (Alphabet, Amazon, Apple, Meta, Microsoft, Nvidia, and Tesla), all of which, apart from Tesla, are in our study. (We count Meta and Alphabet as both tech and media stocks but adjust overall totals to prevent double counting.) The six TMT powerhouses generated almost $8 trillion over five years—more than 50% of the total value created across TMT.
Within individual sectors, a few players dominated value creation:
Technology firms delivered a five-year TSR of 20%. This is an increase of 7 percentage points since we last reported the five-year TSR figure in our 2023 report, a remarkable boost.
Many of the top-ranked companies are manufacturing chips or are involved in their design or testing; they make up seven of the top ten companies by TSR ranking. Demand is soaring. Partly, this is due to the digitization of modern society, with every product, from doorbells to cars, getting increased processing power. But there has been an additional recent surge because generative AI systems such as ChatGPT and other large language models require vast computing power.
Another driver is the shift to cloud computing, which has delivered growth not only for Amazon and other giants but for some specialists too. Taiwan’s Wiwynn, for instance, which provides servers and storage for large data centers, had a five-year TSR of 51% and was one of the top-20 ranked firms by this metric.
For other companies, a leaner cost structure and the return of investor favor proved to be a powerful combination.
Both cost control and the drive to the cloud are evident at Amazon, where margins have improved after the company implemented a cost optimization process that reduced the cost of sales, marketing spending, general and administrative costs, and fulfillment expenses as a percentage of revenue. Amazon also enjoyed top-line growth in many areas, such as advertising revenues, which rose by 24% in 2023. It expects its AWS cloud-computing division to start benefiting from the expansion in GenAI. The company was a top-five value creator in TMT, generating $836 billion over five years.
There are strong returns elsewhere. Oracle, for instance, has seen a rapid increase in sales coupled with an improvement in net margin. It invested in its cloud business and partnered with other tech companies, including Microsoft, to penetrate the space further. In 2023, its valuation was also supported by its work in building infrastructure to support AI workloads and integrating GenAI into a wide array of products and services. Oracle generated $145 billion in value over five years, putting it in the top 20 companies by value creation.
The biggest beneficiary of the drive for AI was Nvidia, the most dramatic rollercoaster story in this report. In 2022, it posted a one-year TSR of –50% after US export regulations banned sales of its most powerful chips to Mainland China. The company was also hit by weak sales of its chips for computer gaming. Its resurgence in 2023 was largely due to its super-powerful processors, such as its H100, widely used for AI training. By the end of 2023, Nvidia’s five-year TSR was 72%, with value creation of $1.1 trillion—and the company generated a further $1 trillion in value during the first quarter of 2024, helped by blowout fourth-quarter results.
By subsector:
For more details about each subsector, see the slideshow below.
Companies in the media sector experienced a strong rebound as they moved beyond their postpandemic hangover. Their five-year TSR rose to 13% from the previous 4%, putting them at a creditable 13th of the 33 sectors we track.
Performance varied substantially; some of TMT’s biggest value creators were in the media sector, along with some of the most challenged companies.
A big driver of the sector’s value creation was Meta. Its five-year value creation was $533 billion, more than a quarter of the entire media sector and a remarkable change from the –$197 billion in 2018–2022 (yes, that is a minus sign at the front of that figure). The company more than recovered from 2022, which was a year of woes caused by many factors, including the economy, changes to the advertising ecosystem, and investors recalibrating their long-term growth forecasts.
In contrast, 2023 saw Meta revenues rise strongly through innovations such as the use of AI to increase engagement on its Facebook and Instagram platforms. The company also benefited from improved margins after its “Year of Efficiency” campaign in 2023; its operating margin in the last quarter of 2023 was 41%, a substantial improvement from the 20% a year earlier. Underlying most of this is the long-term trend toward the digitization of advertising—one estimate reckons Meta captures as much as 18% of all digital ad revenues worldwide. A sign of its financial strength: in February 2024, the company announced it would pay its first dividend.
By subsector:
Movies and Entertainment. There were big winners here and some players with substantial challenges: netted out, the five-year TSR was 4%. The victors were digital and streaming players such as Roku, which has transformed itself from a device manufacturer to a major streaming platform, generating a 24% five-year TSR. Netflix was another success story, with a five-year TSR of 13%, showing flexibility in its business model in late 2022 by introducing an ad-supported tier in some markets (similar to many other streaming services).
The ranks of the challenged included companies that historically relied on revenues from cable TV channels. These firms sometimes try to adapt by offering streaming services, but this new business model is structurally less profitable for traditional networks owing to significantly higher operating costs, reduced per-customer revenues, and greater churn caused by low switching costs. Traditional film is another business model under stress: despite Barbenheimer, global box office receipts in 2023 were 22% lower than five years ago, according to industry data.
Telcos, too, have been under pressure to become more profitable. Multiple organization-wide cost transformation programs coupled with the adoption of digital tools to drive automation have had an effect: margins have improved, and investors have become more confident.
But telco business models remain utility-like, doing relatively well in challenging times such as 2022 but underperforming in a robust investment environment like 2023. No surprise, then, that this sector’s five-year TSR was 6%, far below the S&P 1200’s TSR of 13%, putting it 31st out of the 33 sectors we track.
Nevertheless, telcos have many ways to avoid commoditization, including:
GenAI presents a massive opportunity for the telco industry because it can catalyze a profound transformation along the entire value chain. From cutting costs to creating new products and experiences, the benefits of GenAI are tangible and far-reaching. For instance, GenAI-enabled customer service is expected to be able to reduce service interactions by 50% or more while improving customer satisfaction.
Although large-scale applications are still to come, first movers in commercializing this technology within the telco sector may very well populate the upper levels of the TSR rankings in future years.
To discover the seven ways telcos can generate value in 2024 and beyond, see The 2024 Telco Value Creators Report.
The rebound for TSR and value creation in 2023 was remarkable. But much more is possible if managers consider these three strategies:
We have already underlined how this technology, particularly GenAI, has begun to drive value creation for TMT companies. But the revolution is just starting. A sign of its potential: ChatGPT reached 100 million users just two months after launch, a milestone that took TikTok nine months and Instagram 2.5 years, according to Sensor Tower data. OpenAI, the company that created ChatGPT, saw its revenues spike from a reported $34 million in 2021 to an annualized $2 billion in 2023.
In terms of internal use, initial deployments look very promising. For example, GenAI-enabled conversational assistants have led, in individual cases, to a 14% increase in productivity for customer service agents. GenAI can also drive down the cost of software development—a significant expense for many in TMT. BCG data from pilot projects indicates that mid-level developers with two to four years of experience save 2.5 hours daily with a GenAI coding tool (although other developers save less). AT&T recently launched an internal GenAI tool to improve coding productivity and quickly translate documents into different languages.
But it would be a mistake to see AI just as an internal efficiency tool. AI can improve the top line, such as by boosting customer experience. As noted earlier, Meta used it to drive user engagement on its Facebook and Instagram platforms. Another example is Synopsys, which created the industry’s first full-stack AI-driven chip design suite. The company said in 2023 that nine of the world’s top ten semiconductor companies were using the product. Synopsys has been a consistent top performer on TSR and, for its size, value creation: five-year TSR was 44% and, over the same period, it created $66 billion in value—remarkable for a company with a market value of around $13 billion at the start of our five-year survey period.
The impact is not limited to tech companies. Media companies can use AI in their workflow, such as creating storyboards from scripts or building 3D models at scale for video games. They can also use AI to slash the cost of tasks such as dubbing and localizing content.
For telcos, AI can drive down customer service costs, transform network design and maintenance, create compelling personalized offerings (reducing churn), and more. In an industry like telecommunications with narrow margins and low growth, the impact can be significant.
Developing or selecting an AI technology is only the first stage, however. To successfully develop and deploy GenAI, managers must embrace the “10-20-70” rule, which recommends spending 10% of the effort on building algorithms, 20% on deploying tech stacks and creating high-quality data feeds, and 70% on transforming the operations.
Managers must:
And comprehensive change management must underpin all these efforts.
Every company, inside and outside of TMT, needs to consider where and how it can harness GenAI’s power and consider the fundamental changes required in tools, processes, and people management to turn GenAI’s magic into business impact.
A focus on costs is the other key factor in the TMT sector’s comeback in 2023, and it will be vital in the future.
But this is not cost cutting in the traditional sense, which typically lacks any vision of how to restore growth. This strategic flaw leads to low morale, overloaded teams, and dampened momentum for strategic initiatives owing to frequent changes made by management. Because managers often fail to accurately forecast how the cost cuts will affect growth, they damage essential functions in the quest to rapidly reduce spending instead of thinking more deeply about people, processes, and technology.
Managers must therefore not just cut costs but reimagine them. They need to assess areas of growth, business strategy, and current costs from the perspective of the customer value proposition. The assessment should cover R&D, the cost of production, and other drivers of spending while implementing these principles:
One lesson of the value creation data for 2022 and 2023 is that cost reimagination is not only beneficial in an investment winter; it is of immense value when the sun shines, too. Amazon, Microsoft, and Meta are among the companies that improved TSR in 2023 because of their focus on costs. IBM is another giant driving cost reduction; it is about halfway through a program that aims to save about $3 billion a year, some of it through automation and AI, part of which is being ploughed back into productivity improvements and investments in technical skills.
Broadly, M&A is widely tipped to ramp up in 2024, even though interest rates are falling less quickly than expected. For TMT, though, there are additional reasons that deals are expected to rebound.
In 2023, deal value in TMT plummeted in line with reduced overall valuations and a focus on low-cost assets.
But the announcement by Cisco in September 2023 that it would spend $28 billion to buy Splunk, an analytics and big data company, potentially signaled the start of a new era of M&A opportunity. Since then, more big deals have been announced in the sector, including Synopsys’s $35 billion acquisition of Ansys and HPE’s $14 billion purchase of Juniper Networks.
We see two main strands of M&A activity in TMT:
But tech firms, which have the deepest pockets, face multiple barriers to doing deals. The largest of them face heightened regulatory constraints and need to plough capital into AI-related investments. Deals by other companies may be constrained by the continued higher cost of capital, and many companies may opt for transactions that are either smaller in scale or optimize capital allocation through partial ownership or joint ventures.
Although 2023 saw a sharp upturn in value creation, especially in the tech sector, many challenges persist. Geopolitical uncertainty continues to be intense, and a timetable for falling interest rates remains uncertain—indeed, a resurgence of inflation may keep rate cuts on hold or even trigger increases.
But the rapid bounce back from the problems of 2022 shows that the TMT sectors can adjust with agility. The three strategies above—seizing the opportunities of AI, reimagining costs, and pursuing smart M&A—can help managers drive value creation yet further. If the big picture remains stable, the TMT sectors should continue this strong era of value creation.
Managing Director & Senior Partner; Global Leader, Technology, Media, & Telecommunications Practice
Singapore
ABOUT BOSTON CONSULTING GROUP
Boston Consulting Group partners with leaders in business and society to tackle their most important challenges and capture their greatest opportunities. BCG was the pioneer in business strategy when it was founded in 1963. Today, we work closely with clients to embrace a transformational approach aimed at benefiting all stakeholders—empowering organizations to grow, build sustainable competitive advantage, and drive positive societal impact.
Our diverse, global teams bring deep industry and functional expertise and a range of perspectives that question the status quo and spark change. BCG delivers solutions through leading-edge management consulting, technology and design, and corporate and digital ventures. We work in a uniquely collaborative model across the firm and throughout all levels of the client organization, fueled by the goal of helping our clients thrive and enabling them to make the world a better place.
© Boston Consulting Group 2024. All rights reserved.
For information or permission to reprint, please contact BCG at permissions@bcg.com. To find the latest BCG content and register to receive e-alerts on this topic or others, please visit bcg.com. Follow Boston Consulting Group on Facebook and X (formerly Twitter).